By Leigh Sanders
Over the weekend acclaimed movie director Peter Jackson announced that both Sir Ian McKellen and Andy Serkis had agreed to reprise their roles as Gandalf and Gollum in his much beleaguered two-part adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s ‘The Hobbit.’
On football pitches up and down the country magic of a very different nature was occurring. It was FA Cup third round weekend; one of the most exciting three days of the English footballing calendar.
It is a time and place where non-league, part-time clubs can lock horns with their multi-million corporation counterparts from the Premier League. A level playing field which could pitch a milkman, a maths teacher and a window cleaner against the pampered egos of top flight football. It is very much David vs. Goliath.
Recent years have seen the competition’s stature dwindle somewhat among the country’s leading clubs. Many see Premier League survival or Champions League qualification (or rather the financial benefits of each scenario) as more important than the every-man-for-himself glory of progressing through the draw to Wembley and a chance to lift one of the world’s most famous trophies.
Following their unprecedented domestic treble in 1999 Manchester United opted out of defending the FA Cup in the 99/2000 season in order to take their place in FIFA’s new World Club Championships which got underway place on third round weekend.
Since that decision many have questioned the modern value of the FA Cup as more and more top sides field weaker teams against “lesser” opposition from lower divisions. The Football Association (FA) have recently talked about renovating the competition by eliminating aspects such as the reply to help ease fixture congestion and keep larger clubs interested.
Yet the FA Cup replay is what keeps most of the smaller clubs hooked. Take, for example, Blue Square Premier side York City who travelled to Premier League Bolton Wanderers this weekend for their third round tie. Defending expertly and earning a draw would mean not only plaudits and your name up in bright lights but also a chance to get at your more illustrious opposition in your own back yard, where they will be less comfortable, and perhaps snatch an unlikely victory. The said reply will also be a high earner for York with a sell-out crowd guaranteed and an extra mound of income should Sky Sports choose to televise the tie.
At a time of such financial uncertainty for most football clubs why rob teams like York of a wad of extra cash which could help keep staff employed? With relations between the FA and the Premier League as strained as ever the governing body of English football should be defending the smaller sides, not making life harder for them in order to appease the financial giants.
But while the higher echelons of the English game were having their loyalties questioned the action on the pitch once again laughed off any possibility of disinterest in the FA Cup from players and supporters alike.
At Arsenal’s Emirates Stadium nearly 9,000 Leeds United fans travelled south to cheer their team on hoping for a repeat of last year’s third round where they made the short trip over The Pennines to face fierce rivals Manchester United and came away with a shock 1-0 victory. It was Sir Alex Ferguson’s first defeat at this hurdle of the competition in his entire tenure at Old Trafford. They almost dished out the same treatment to Arsene Wenger. Leading 1-0 through a Robert Snodgrass stonewall penalty it took a last minute questionable pen from Cesc Fabregas, after Theo Walcott seemed to tumble a little too easily inside the area, to level things up and earn Arsenal a second chance up at Leeds’ Elland Road where a partisan Yorkshire crowd will make life extremely difficult for the Londoners.
Reading overcame Premier League West Bromwich Albion thanks to a well taken goal from Ireland international Shane Long while Notts County pulled off a much deserved if sparsely predicted 2-1 win at Sunderland’s Stadium of Light. There were also victories over higher division opposition for Burton Albion, Brighton & Hove Albion, Sheffield Wednesday, Leyton Orient, Southampton, Crawley Town and Torquay United. Sven Goran Eriksson’s Leicester City earned a replay with the world’s richest club Manchester City after a hard fought and vastly entertaining 2-2 draw at the Walkers Stadium, Cardiff City will replay with Stoke City after a 1-1 draw at The Britannia Stadium and Doncaster Rovers will get a replay at Wolves’ Molineux stadium after a 2-2 draw at their own Keepmoat home.
Yet the greatest story of the weekend came from Broadway Hall where League Two Stevenage Borough ran out 3-1 victors over Premier League Newcastle United to avenge their feisty and somewhat unfortunate defeat to the Magpies in the fourth round back in 1998.
Goals, bookings, a sending off and even Stevenage left back Scott Laird getting punched and knocked out by his own fan over an ex-girlfriend. This match had everything!
Newcastle fielded a strong side containing many Premier League regulars and experienced internationals which makes the result even better for Graham Westley’s Stevenage, who he had told to go and win this one 5-0. If there is anybody still questioning the “magic” of the FA Cup then they should just be handed a DVD of this match to shut them up.
I hope the bigwigs at the Football Association thinking of altering this excellent format were taking note too. It is one of the remaining bastions of old-worldy football where money has no bearing and you are only as good as your performance on the pitch.
To chop and change this around would kill off the hopes of every “little man” in the sport and would completely engulf football in a blanket made of cash. It would be the death of our favourite pastime as we know it. And then we might as well pack it all in and find ourselves a new hobby. Knitting anyone?



